Mrs. McGinnis has been married to her husband Mike for 38 years. They have two daughters, Emory (ECS Class of 1999) and Courtney (ECS Class of 2003). Emory is married to Bradley Eison, and they are parents of two daughters. Courtney is married to Gaines Conaway, and they live in Germantown with their two children. Mr. and Mrs. McGinnis are active members of Collierville Baptist Church.